3458 Anglin Drive, Sarasota, FL 34242
For Sale $2,495,000
Save Property
Located in the highly desirable Bay Island neighborhood, this beautifully updated, move-in-ready Key West-style residence offers an appealing combination of privacy, space, and convenience. Known as the "Gateway to Siesta Key," Bay Island enjoys a prime location near the north bridge, providing easy access to Siesta Key's beaches and village, as well as downtown Sarasota's dining, shopping, and cultural attractions. Set on an expansive 14,400-square-foot double lot—an uncommon offering on Siesta Key—the property is surrounded by mature tropical landscaping, creating a private setting with generous outdoor living spaces. The home's open floor plan features vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, and a natural gas fireplace. French doors connect the main living areas to multiple covered terraces, extending the living space outdoors. The kitchen features a large quartzite island, custom cabinetry, generous storage, and a full suite of Thermador appliances. The primary suite is located on the main living level, along with a flexible fourth bedroom or den. On the third floor, two spacious guest bedrooms share a newly renovated bathroom and enjoy access to an elevated terrace. Outdoor amenities include a heated saltwater pool, travertine decking, an outdoor shower, and ample space for relaxing or entertaining within the landscaped grounds. Extensively renovated in 2019 and further improved in subsequent years, the home features updated major systems, hurricane-rated windows and French doors, retractable screens, whole-house water filtration, and additional upgrades. Meticulously maintained and move-in ready, this Bay Island property offers an uncommon combination of lot size, privacy, location, and updated living spaces on Siesta Key.
Ceiling Fans(s)
Crown Molding
Eat-in Kitchen
High Ceilings
Kitchen/Family Room Combo
Living Room/Dining Room Combo
Open Floorplan
Solid Wood Cabinets
Stone Counters
Thermostat
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Walk-In Closet(s)
Window Treatments
Taxes: $19,659.00
Tax Year: 2025
Balcony
Lighting
Storage
Convection Oven
Dishwasher
Disposal
Dryer
Freezer
Gas Water Heater
Microwave
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
Washer
Water Filtration System
Pool
Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
Middle School: Brookside Middle
Junior High: Brookside Middle
High School: Sarasota High
Building Description: Elevated, Florida, Key West
MLS Area: 34242 - Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
Total Square Footage: 6,151
Price per Square Feet: $992.84
Total Floors: 3
Water: Public
Construction: Block, Hardi Plank Type, Frame
Date Listed: 2026-11-05 00:00:00
Pool: Y
Pool Description: Gunite, Heated, In Ground, Lighting, Salt Water
Furnished: Unfurnished
Windows: Skylight(S), Storm Window(S)
Parking: Driveway, Garage Door Opener
Garage Description: Y
Attached Garage: Y
Flooring: Carpet, Luxury Vinyl
Roof: Shingle
Heating: Central
Cooling: Central Air, Mini-Split Unit(S)
Fireplace: Y
Laundry: Inside, Laundry Room
Sewer: Public Sewer
Lot Desc.: Flood Zone, City Limits, Landscaped, Oversized Lot, Paved
Parcel ID: 2019100041
Listing Courtesy Of: Michael Saunders & Company
fredsassen@michaelsaunders.com
Located in the highly desirable Bay Island neighborhood, this beautifully updated, move-in-ready Key West-style residence offers an appealing combination of privacy, space, and convenience. Known as the "Gateway to Siesta Key," Bay Island enjoys a prime location near the north bridge, providing easy access to Siesta Key's beaches and village, as well as downtown Sarasota's dining, shopping, and cultural attractions. Set on an expansive 14,400-square-foot double lot—an uncommon offering on Siesta Key—the property is surrounded by mature tropical landscaping, creating a private setting with generous outdoor living spaces. The home's open floor plan features vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, and a natural gas fireplace. French doors connect the main living areas to multiple covered terraces, extending the living space outdoors. The kitchen features a large quartzite island, custom cabinetry, generous storage, and a full suite of Thermador appliances. The primary suite is located on the main living level, along with a flexible fourth bedroom or den. On the third floor, two spacious guest bedrooms share a newly renovated bathroom and enjoy access to an elevated terrace. Outdoor amenities include a heated saltwater pool, travertine decking, an outdoor shower, and ample space for relaxing or entertaining within the landscaped grounds. Extensively renovated in 2019 and further improved in subsequent years, the home features updated major systems, hurricane-rated windows and French doors, retractable screens, whole-house water filtration, and additional upgrades. Meticulously maintained and move-in ready, this Bay Island property offers an uncommon combination of lot size, privacy, location, and updated living spaces on Siesta Key.
Property Details
Price: $2,495,000
Sq Ft: 2,513
($993 per
sqft)
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2
Partial Baths: 1
City: Sarasota
County: Sarasota
Type: Single Family
Development: Bay Island Park
Acres: 0.3300
Year Built: 1983
Listing Number: A4711117
Status Code: A-Active
Taxes: $19,659.00
Tax Year: 2025
Garage:
Y
Furnishings: Unfurnished
Interior Features:
Ceiling Fans(s)
Crown Molding
Eat-in Kitchen
High Ceilings
Kitchen/Family Room Combo
Living Room/Dining Room Combo
Open Floorplan
Solid Wood Cabinets
Stone Counters
Thermostat
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Walk-In Closet(s)
Window Treatments
Financial Information:
Taxes: $19,659.00
Tax Year: 2025
Exterior Features:
Balcony
Lighting
Storage
Equipment:
Convection Oven
Dishwasher
Disposal
Dryer
Freezer
Gas Water Heater
Microwave
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
Washer
Water Filtration System
View:
Pool
School Information:
Elementary School: Phillippi Shores Elementary
Middle School: Brookside Middle
Junior High: Brookside Middle
High School: Sarasota High
Additional Information:
Building Description: Elevated, Florida, Key West
MLS Area: 34242 - Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
Total Square Footage: 6,151
Price per Square Feet: $992.84
Total Floors: 3
Water: Public
Construction: Block, Hardi Plank Type, Frame
Date Listed: 2026-11-05 00:00:00
Pool: Y
Pool Description: Gunite, Heated, In Ground, Lighting, Salt Water
Furnished: Unfurnished
Windows: Skylight(S), Storm Window(S)
Parking: Driveway, Garage Door Opener
Garage Description: Y
Attached Garage: Y
Flooring: Carpet, Luxury Vinyl
Roof: Shingle
Heating: Central
Cooling: Central Air, Mini-Split Unit(S)
Fireplace: Y
Laundry: Inside, Laundry Room
Sewer: Public Sewer
Lot Desc.: Flood Zone, City Limits, Landscaped, Oversized Lot, Paved
Parcel ID: 2019100041
Map of 3458 Anglin Drive, Sarasota, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: Michael Saunders & Company
fredsassen@michaelsaunders.com